Chuck Stokke - Veteran, Dentist & Environmental Advocate

Oral History Transcript of Chuck Stokke

Interviewer: Clark Grant
Interview Date: August 14, 2024
Location: 1309 W 4th St, Anaconda, MT
Transcribed: July 2025 by Gayla Hess

CLARK GRANT: If you would, can you say and spell your name for me?

CHUCK STOKKE: Charles Daniel Stokey. C-h-a-r-l-e-s. D-a-n-i-e-l. S-t-o-k-k-e.

CLARK: Great. The sound level looks good. Shall we begin?

CHUCK: Sure.

CLARK: Okay. I’m Clark Grant, and I'm here in the Stokke family home, Wednesday, August 14, 2024, and I'd like for you to begin, if you can, to just recollect about your grandparents either on your father or mother’s side wherever you’d like to begin. What do you know about them?

CHUCK: So father’s side was Ollie and Amanda Stokke. They came over from Norway from a town called Midstokkan. His name at that time was Danielson, but they didn't want to sound like they came from the old country, so they changed it, and named themselves from the town they came from, Stokka, so that’s how I became Stokke. And that’s where my middle name came from, Daniel, from the old family name, Danielson.

So, they came right from Norway to here and things were pretty tough as I understand it in Norway at that time, and he went to work on the smelter. As far as I know, they rented a home on East 4th Street and pretty much the crew in the converters was Norwegian, so that is where he went to work in the converters. As they spoke English better and better, then they could move to other spots, but that’s kind of where the Norwegians were. He may have worked in the roasters for a while, not positive of that.

But they rented that house on East 4th, raised three children in that house which is a little bigger than this room. All three kids, there were two girls and my father, all got college degrees. The two gals became nurses at MSU and my dad went to MSU. A lot of their friends were Norwegians. I can remember as a child going to the Sons of Norway dinners and celebrations and stuff, so.

His mother, Amatah, just stayed home. He was a fisherman, not a lot of big hobbies and stuff, but tickled to death to be in America.

CLARK: Any idea what was going on in Norway that drove them out?

CHUCK: I don’t.

CLARK: Do you know how they got here?

CHUCK: I don’t.

CLARK: Do you know approximately what year?

CHUCK: It was around 1900, so yeah, the smelter was a little different in those days than now, it was around then. Um, but I don’t know the exact year.

CLARK: Do you think that they must have had friends here and that’s why they?

CHUCK: Oh sure.

CLARK: Why do you think it is that Norwegians worked in the converters? Why did they put them there?

CHUCK: I have no idea. No idea.

CLARK: It’s kind of like the Finlanders used to drive the shafts, you know, what I mean.

CHUCK: Right.

CLARK: I don’t know why, yeah. So, did you meet them?

CHUCK: Yeah, I spent a lot of time with them.

CLARK: Great. Can we hear more about that? I’m curious about the food, in particular.

CHUCK: So, that was, I grew up on Main Street, just below the courthouse, so it was an easy walk to their house. So yeah, as I got a little older, was a little more mobile I would go down and visit them. We had a lot of holidays with them, especially Christmas, so it was lutefisk, lefse. She was a good cook. There were always molasses cookies and crumb cakes. My sister has all those recipes now. She still makes the crumb cakes, but we’ve given up on lefse and the lutefisk. Not what you’d call gourmet fair, but the family’s dinners were a treat.

[5:05]

CHUCK: On the other side of the family which we can get to, the grandparents on my mother’s side, my grandfather’s mother had a brother named Harry who had a colorful past, it was always my job at Christmas time to go pick up Harry from the boardinghouse. He was an old alcoholic. We would all have a cocktail before Harry got then, and then I would go pick Harry up and the drinking would stop. Harry would always be looking for a glass to get something.

So, I’ve been in some of the old Sladich boardinghouses on 3rd street, he moved from place to place down there to get Harry, and it was always kind of a treat for me. Part of that time I was going to be a dentist and Harry would run around and rummage through the drawers to find his teeth so he could put his teeth in for Christmas dinner. He was absolutely stone deaf. He was a blacksmith on the smelter, you know, anvils and stuff, played the piano in the silent movies, very loudly. He could still play. We had a piano at our house in Anaconda when he came there up on Main Street. He could still play. Some of my fondest memories of he and Olie having a conversation, so Olie spoke broken English, so the Norwegian, and Harry couldn’t hear. So, I mean, it should have been a movie. [laughter] You look at what’s going on in reality TV now, and it’s just awesome, but yeah…two good gentlemen.

CLARK: And so, Harry was related, he was your mother’s father’s brother, is that right?

CHUCK: So, my grandfather’s mother’s brother.

CLARK: I see. Ok.

CHUCK: I can give you the genealogy, it’s all written out on that part of the family, and they’ve got back into the 1830s, but I think my great grandfather was born in 1872, one of ten children. He worked for the BAP, an accountant, at what now is ABC Building or A1 building in that building. He died the year I was born, so that would be Frank Gorr. He died the year I was born in the year 1948 on August 12th and was born on August 12th and was married on August 12th. Two of those could be planned, somewhat, but the 3rd one not so much.

CLARK: That’s right.

CHUCK: He drowned on Georgetown fishing with a dentist.

CLARK: Oh really? Sad.

CHUCK: Interesting guy. So where were we, back to Harry? Oh, talking about the grandparents, Olie and Amanda.

CLARK: Yeah.

CHUCK: I can remember fishing with him at the lake, but otherwise recreation, not so much. The food was pretty much memorable in what I’ve told you. She was a good cook, but otherwise it was holidays that we ate there. Yeah, so, but I knew them pretty well.

CLARK: Did he talk about his work?

CHUCK: No. No, I kind of knew what went on at the smelter, but yeah, didn’t dwell on that at all, mostly talked about playing cards with the Halsteds, pinocle.

CLARK: That sounds like fun too.

CHUCK: It was just, yeah.

CLARK: So, they had a vibrant social life you would say?

CHUCK: Yeah, lot of friends in that part of town, you know, the houses were close together, small. I think the Lutheran church was on the same block, maybe two blocks away, that they went to, small neighborhood groups.

CLARK: Yeah, I was going to ask about their faith or their church life. Were they devout?

CHUCK: Um, yeah, but I don’t know – I never went to church with them. My family had the Episcopal church right across the street so that’s where we went. So, yeah, not so much.

CLARK: How long have they been gone?

CHUCK: I think in the ‘70s they both died. He had heart problems which is where my father’s came from and mine came from, it’s all genetics, heart problems. He died of a stroke. I can remember him being in the hospital and pretty ill in those days, the medicine wasn’t good enough to take care of a lot of that. It wasn’t cancer that killed him, it was the heart attack, or smelter-related illnesses.

[10:35]

CLARK: I’m not as well versed as I should be in how the smelter actually functioned. What takes place in the converters? What would he have been exposed to?

CHUCK: Well, I think your exposure would be from the time you walked in the door of the plant until you left the plant.

CLARK: Yeah.

CHUCK: Besides the emissions from the stack, I mean, a ton of things came off the roasters and converters, the dust from the crushers, you know, filtration plants, chemicals. So, there’s all kinds of ways to get in trouble up there. Accidents, probably, were the leading cause.

The converter aisle was the last step, well not the last, but almost the last step where they took it from the roasters and put it in the big furnaces to get the final impurities out of it, the slag. And then they took it down from the converters in cranes and ladles down to the casting wheel where they actually poured the metal into anodes, so, if you see some of the big pictures of those big, big, cylinders with the flames coming out of them, those are the converters, and cranes up above, you know, guys working the cranes, hauling ‘em down the aisle, a lot of fire, a lot of gases coming off. All those gases are what went out the stack, off of the converter aisles. So, when you first walk into that place it was like, I’ve entered hell.

CLARK: It sounds hellish.

CHUCK: Yeah.

CLARK: Yeah, that’s why I asked if he ever talked about work. I mean, I would be complaining all the time, I think, if I worked there.

CHUCK: Yeah, but for them it was a good living, you know. Yeah, so, times were good in town. Everybody had money, so yeah, at least as far as I know.

CLARK: Yeah. How about your mother’s side, can we return to that, to Harry and them.

CHUCK: So, my mother’s father were Sonny and Jane. I think Sonny was born in 1900. Jane’s family history is a little murkier. His is pretty well documented. He’s one of three children. His father worked for the BAP as we mentioned, as an accountant in the office there, and was one of ten children. I think that family came from east Texas, er Pennsylvania, Missouri, they moved all over the place. A lot of brothers and sisters there, but Frank got out here.

Sonny and his two sisters lived, I think, on Spruce Street, grew up, born on Spruce Street. And then there was a family house, I’ll have to go look at the history, on 208 E 3rd, and then the family home that his mother lived on was on Maple Street so very local family.

But Sonny and Jane, I think Sonny may have graduated from 8th grade. I don’t know a lot about the early jobs, but became a mechanic, lived in Idaho for a bit of a time, had a bit of a problem in the Mormon culture.

CLARK: A problem?

CHUCK: Well, if you weren’t a Mormon, you weren’t part of the culture, so.

CLARK: I see.

CHUCK: His wife, Jane, was very much not a Mormon. We can get into the religion part of it which is really kind of fun too.

CLARK: Sounds good.

CHUCK: So Sonny eventually ended up with the car barns. So, you know, I was born in ’48 by then, he’s in his 40s and pretty well established in what’s going on. So, where the liquor store is in Anaconda now, used to be a building called Central Motor Company, he owned that. He had a Buick dealership in there, pretty much that lasted until around the early ‘50s, but he kept the GMC dealership and mechanic, sold GMCs, had a gas station on the corner as part of that so I worked there as a kid a lot in and out of that. He also, with a couple of partners, owned the car barns where the credit union is on that block now. That was a massive old barn-like warehouse, held, I don’t know, maybe 18-20 school buses, a tire recap business, machine shop for all the guys doing work on smelter stuff, the school buses, you know, recap tires – did a lot of repair work on the other side. I worked there too.

CLARK: Quite the empire.

CHUCK: It was and just from scratch, absolutely from nothing.

Sonny was very active in Anaconda, just one of those guys that knew everybody and had a lot of contacts and a lot of friends. A lot of friends out of diverse places, it wasn’t just mechanics that he hung with and probably the least number of friends he had were mechanics.

My grandmother was very religious, Episcopalian, a very big part of the church up here on Main Street, active that way. They had one only child, my mother. So, Sonny is probably the more colorful character in the whole story of things going on. I’ve been asked to speak on him at the historical talk in December.

CLARK: Oh, great. Okay.

CHUCK: Yeah, so that’s going to be a 15-minute presentation. But, yeah, he had his fingers in a lot of stuff and would, you know, fiddle around with a lot of stuff. He was the first person I worked for when I was 13 I went to work for Sonny. I worked for him on the weekends way before then, working out at the lake. When I went to the car barns, it was a union shop, and so at 13 I got a Teamster’s card.

CLARK: Wow.

[17:32]

CHUCK: Didn’t get paid like a Teamster, but I had to join the union to work there. So, Sonny bought my Teamster’s membership, paid the dues, and he said, explained to me, this is part of the game, don’t worry about it, you don’t have to do anything. Later on in life, that Teamster’s card, I put to use.

CLARK: Hm.

CHUCK: So, I started out sorting nuts and bolts in the car barns up there, you know, one summer. They had barrels of bolts and nuts, extra, that I spent the summer cleaning and sorting, so, kids these days bitch about work and I just look at them like, give me a break.

I started drinking coffee at 13 with all the boys for the break at 10 o’clock in the morning. But they were adamant that I not learn how to become a mechanic, you know, so it’s like, can I help you work on this, I want to learn how to tune my carburetor; no, get lost, that’s not going to happen so that was good.

CLARK: Yeah, maybe they were doing you a favor by not teaching you that trade.

CHUCK: Yeah, I think so, there was a plan in place.

CLARK: When you give a talk about him, about Sonny, what are some things you plan to focus on?

CHUCK: Well, he wasn’t a huge outdoorsman, but he loved to tinker with a lot of machinery related to that. He actually owned a snow plane. So, I don’t know if you know what a snow plane is, but there’s a lot of pictures of them in the Big Hole. I don’t know if they were invented out there, but that’s where they were made. It’s a precursor to the snowmobiles that we have now. There’s a single ski in the front and two skis on the side. The whole frame was like an aircraft, a Super Cub, it was all aluminum tubing. There was a seat inside, steering wheel like a car, dead man throttle on the stick, and an airplane engine mounted behind. And so, you would get behind this thing and hand start it, turning the prop on the plane engine, get it going, get inside and the airplane engine would push forward, no brakes.

Sonny used to go to the Big Hole, and I went out with him a couple of times because a lot of the Hershy ranches had them. A lot of the Big Hole ranchers had them. There was a lot more snow out there in those days. The river floor was up really well up there. They would race up and down the river, in the roads in the Big Hole, through the fields, over the fences. It was a big deal. When I went out with him, when a guy was building it for him, a guy named Grassley, I think, in Wisdom. So, we went out to supervise what he was doing with the construction of the thing. Kind of what amazes me now is, they used to let me run this thing by myself at Georgetown Lake. I’d take it from the cabin and go out on the lake, would chase coyotes across the ice.

CLARK: Whoa.

CHUCK: Would I let my kids do that now? No way.

CLARK: That sounds really exhilarating.

CHUCK: Yeah, it was pretty cool. In the car barns, he had all the room to keep this stuff. There was an old fire engine there. He built floats for Anaconda for the smeltermen’s parade that had the stack with smoke coming out of the stack. That was a big deal for us to go to that.

The very first snow cat in Anaconda, he and his partner, had two big old polarises. I got some photos of those. I mean massive things, just heavy. There was no way if it tipped over one guy could tip it back up. It would probably take probably three or four guys to do that. But, those guys could travel into all the mountain lakes in the winter time and fish where nobody else fished and go where nobody else went in those days. I think there were four guys that ended up with from Anaconda. They had some interesting stories with all that stuff, so yeah, it was kind of interesting.

CLARK: I’ve heard of those machines, that’s fascinating.

CHUCK: Oh yeah, I got pictures of them still.

[22:06]

He played Santa Claus for the kids in the winter time, you know at Christmas at Park Café, you ever heard of the Park Café in Anaconda?

CLARK: Yeah.

CHUCK: Well, he was good friends with Kelsey and Bill. They used to live on the other end, first house of the next block. They owned the Park Café. So, Sonny would go in and the Chief of Police, Mike Morris, would be in there and they would hand out all the presents to the kids. Sonny would, every Christmas he got a big bag. His whole front porch was filled with candy canes to give out, so he went to lots of places playing Santa Claus. That was my job for years to chauffeur him around and pick up Christmas and all that stuff. Pretty interesting.

CLARK: Would you drive around to schools and stuff or?

CHUCK: He went to the orphanages down at Twin Bridges.

CLARK: Oh wow.

CHUCK: Yeah, a lot of different places. Christmas night we would go to a lot of people’s houses, I think his teacher friends or priest friends, you know would say stuff a lot of times. A lot of his friends just to surprise them if a thought popped into his head, so, it was a fun evening. I think he did just stuff everywhere, a lot of random stuff that I’m sure I didn’t even know about, but yeah. The budget for candy canes was, that must have been massive in those days.

CLARK: [laughter] He sounds like a very generous man.

[23:40]

CHUCK: Yeah. One of the fun stories about him is he ran all the school buses. It was pretty much a flat contract as I understand it, it was cost plus ten percent. The schools were getting a good deal. They knew what they were going to pay all the time. So that’s when Central was open, the Catholic school, so of course, that didn’t come under the tax thing, so Sonny hauled all the Catholic kids for free. That ingratiated him to all the priests so Sonny and the priests in the Catholic community were pretty tight.

He tells an interesting story. One year, his wife was big in the Episcopal church and donated to that. His mother was a Christian Scientist. Sonny was in tight with the Catholics and donated to them, so on his income tax return he had donations of about $1500 in those days, to each church. He got audited by the IRS, they didn’t believe him. So, my grandmother had good records for the church and his mother supplied the stuff, you know, from getting it from the other church. So, Sonny said, I went to Father Murray, telling him, asking him that I need records for my donation for the church last year because I’m getting audited. He said, Father Murray said to me “What donation, Sonny?”

CLARK: Oh no.

CHUCK: [laughter] He said, what do you mean? “I don’t remember that. You want to make a donation to the church?” and then he laughed like hell and said “How much do you need?” So, you know, stuff like that.

He had big dinners every year at the Echo Lake Lodge which is gone now. It was for the principals, the priests, the nuns, a lot of the people that were his employees, family like that at Echo Lake Lodge. It was big fun. That was his way of taking care of people, thanking them. The guy that owned Echo Lake Lodge was a big buddy of his. A fun party.

CLARK: Yeah, he sounds very magnanimous.

CHUCK: Yeah. He really liked the Montana Hotel and tried to save that. He was one of the instigators of the big stock program they had. So people say now, oh, you know, they need to do something, they should have saved that hotel. They tried really hard. He had tons of old worthless stock certificates when he died from there. I had stock certificates that somebody bought for me when I was a kid, trying to save that thing, put a lot of money to it.

CLARK: Can you tell us about that for people who have never heard of that story?

CHUCK: Um, I don’t know all of the particulars. Sally Camwell was running the place at the time, I remember. Her husband was, I don’t know if she was in radio at the time, you’ll have to look back and see about that, but her husband was the principal, I think, at the high school or the junior high maybe, the junior high at the time. She was always a manager down there, and the place was kind of a going concern in the early days. It was still pretty active, but I don’t know how much it was making money, probably not well enough.

They had a restaurant in there when I was a kid. The bar was going when I was probably in college still. But, all the ins and outs of it, for all the money, blood, sweat, and tears people poured into it; it didn’t happen eventually it got bought up and dismantled. So, yeah, but there was a pretty big effort a long time ago.

CLARK: Yeah, and Sonny was part of that.

CHUCK: Yeah.

[27:51]

CLARK: Was he political at all? Did he ever seek office or anything?

CHUCK: Yeah, he did, one time.

CLARK: Ok.

CHUCK: But he was a staunch Republican and in Anaconda or Butte, not gonna work. But he came really close to getting elected. He ran against a guy named Dupie Fitzpatrick who worked in the garage on the smelter, a good union guy. Basically, yeah, I think it was political R vs. D.

CLARK: OK.

CHUCK: In retrospect he always said, boy, I’m glad I never got elected in that job.

CLARK: What office was he seeking?

CHUCK: County Commissioner.

CLARK: Oh, I see.

CHUCK: Yeah.

CLARK: Ok.

CHUCK: I’ve still got a lot of the campaign memorabilia tucked away some place.

CLARK: Oh, that’s cool, and Sonny’s last name again, if you don’t mind?

CHUCK: Gorr, G-O-R-R.

CLARK: Gorr, ok. And so, your mother was his only child?

CHUCK: Yes.

CLARK: Interesting. What was it like having him as a father, you think?

CHUCK: Win would tell you, and I would agree with her, he was very independent. It was like this is what we’re going to do, and this is what happened. So, he made up his mind and you know, so. For example, he bought me a motor scooter when I was 12. [laughter] And it’s like are you kidding, a kid is not going to get a license to drive it. Sonny knew the police and he know the probation officer, and if they caught me, they would just tell me to go home.

CLARK: [laughter]

CHUCK: He pretty much ran the show as far as the house and the business went. The businesses were successful so, notwithstanding the fact that there was a lot of graft and corruption going on behind his back; some of it he knew about, some of it he didn’t.

CLARK: By his employees or?

CHUCK: Oh yeah.

CLARK: Do tell.

CHUCK: It’s interesting the… As he was getting older, [phone rings] excuse me.

CLARK: No problem. You bet. I’ll pause.

CLARK: Great. We were talking a little about Sonny. You were going to say in the old days. I was asking what it was like for your mother to grow up with him as a father.

CHUCK: Um, I think she had a pretty good upbringing. You know, she learned how to play piano, and good student, and I think they spoiled as they should an only child. Yeah, I think she did well.

CLARK: Oh, and you had mentioned that employees were stealing from him. [laughter]

CHUCK: Oh yeah, so and some of this I didn’t find out about until after he died. So, where they sold GMCs, Central Motors where the liquor store is now, he had a guy managing the business for him named Frank O’Neil. Frank and Sonny had breakfast every morning in the Montana Hotel, went over the business blah blah, whatever, you know, needed to be taken care of whether it was mechanics, grease bay, automobiles, part sales. Before he died Frank retired, they went through the books and found out Frank had been embezzling from him for years, taking from him so and that was one of them.

When I went to work for him at the car barns in high school they put me in the tire shop. In the tire shop there was a lot of traffic going on as far as logging truck, smelter trucks, farm equipment, they recapped tires and sold the recaps. As part of that they also ran a truck to Philipsburg, Hall, Drummond, Deer Lodge with all those tires and tire repairs and recaps as part of that. So, Sonny’s partner, a guy named George Forsman, his son ran the tire shop. He did the circuit with the tires to all those cities. So, Sonny even told me, the first summer that I worked for him, the tire shop showed a bigger profit than it ever had. Not because of my work but because the guy that was managing the shop was not reporting all the income that was going in on the loop, and he was afraid I was looking over his shoulder so that he didn’t embezzle from the route during that summer. So that’s how Sonny picked up on what was going on in the tire shop. That guy was a drunk too, so he ran and did all that.

The third part of the story is, as Sonny was getting ready to retire and his health was ill, he was still working. He was talking to my dad about selling the business. So, he had an accountant and they, basically, the accountant and the attorney said that it was not worth that much, you know basically. You know, this is what’s here, but there’s the school buses and stuff but it’s not worth that much so. They put a price on it and Sonny said it’s not worth it for me to sell it. After Sonny died, they were saying well, now we’re thinking about selling it, the accountant and the attorney came to them and said they would offer them this much money which was a little higher than what they had appraised it for. My dad said it’s worth way more than that and brought other people in, and it was worth way more than that so they were basically lowballing him so they could buy the business. Huh? Huh?

[34:22]

CLARK: Why?

CHUCK: Huh?

CLARK: Why? The way you portray Sonny, especially with donning the Santa Claus outfit, it seems like he would, you know, be willing to help these people. They didn’t have to steal from him.

CHUCK: Absolutely. Absolutely. As far as I know everybody was doing pretty well. There was always the labor contracts that had to be renegotiated. I didn’t know anything about those, about how that worked, but it was pretty much standard fare. What anybody got up on the smelter, they were going to get in town too. But I can even remember the Teamsters rep in Anaconda coming and putting a stamp in my little Teamsters card book every year. Pick up my money, Sonny would give me the money to give him, so I could get the stamp.

[phone rings] I’m sorry. I’ll just shut this thing off.

CLARK: Sure, sounds good.

Transcriber’s Note: At 35:20 Chuck takes a call, and the interview resumes at 36:00

CLARK: Speaking of the Teamsters, you had mentioned that the Teamster’s card came in handy later in life, before I forget that thread, I wanted to…

CHUCK: So, one summer when I was going to college, there was, I can’t remember if that’s the summer- on strike or not, but at any rate I got hired by a construction company that was building the flume from Twin Lakes to Silver Lake, replacing the old wooden flume with an asphalt ditch. And so, I got hired through, my dad knew a guy named Don Stanisich who had a construction company at the time, now Jordan Construction. Don and my dad were good friends, and he said, I’ll put Chuck on for the summer as a laborer.

I went up and the first thing they put me with was a carpenter to tear out the old bridge that went over the wooden flume, going up to Storm Lake. We got on that, and the carpenter said to me something about do you have a union card or something, sometimes they’ll come around and check. I said, “well I can renew the Teamsters card.” He said, “That will work.” They had guys running heavy equipment tearing out the bridge. I’m doing scut work with the carpenter. So maybe a month into that job somebody saw, and I think it was the carpenter’s union guy, coming by and I forget where I was, but I wasn’t right there where the rep was. The carpenter came to me and said, “They’re checking everybody to see if they’re in the union.” So, he said, “You were hauling wood and he didn’t see you, but he’s going to come back so be sure you have your Teamsters card with you” cause I told him I had it. So, he said, “You’re qualified to drive truck and load the trucks and stuff, so just tell the union guys that’s what you’re doing. You’re not doing carpenter work.” So that’s how I stayed on the job as part of the union is paying my Teamsters dues for a month working for Don in the summer time.

CLARK: How about Sonny’s wife? We just touched on her briefly, but I was curious if you could tell me more.

CHUCK: Pretty much, you know, stay at home, involved in her church work, had friends and they’d play bridge and cards. She was a big gardener. Other than that, nothing really remarkable.

CLARK: A loving mother to your mother?

CHUCK: Oh absolutely, yeah. All those relationships were close, very good.

CLARK: How about your mother’s upbringing and her schooling?

CHUCK: Graduated Anaconda High and then went to U of M, got a degree from U of M, went to work back in Anaconda. At one point in time, I think she actually worked for the FBI.

CLARK: What?

CHUCK: And then she worked for a guy named Dixie Loughton in the Credit Bureau in Anaconda taking care of books there. I think that was early on right after her college, a little murky on dates for me there. I was born in ’48, the year my father got out of MSU. They had me in Bozeman. I was born in Bozeman in May, and they moved up here in like June or soon after he graduated.

CLARK: Do people jokingly say you’re actually from Bozeman?

CHUCK: I don’t tell them.

CLARK: [laughter] I see. Ok.

CHUCK: Depending on the circumstances, of course.

CLARK: Right. What did your mother study at UM?

CHUCK: I think it was a liberal arts degree, but she may have had some bookkeeping in there to get her on with Dixie.

CLARK: What’s this about the FBI then?

CHUCK: I don’t know all the details of that, but it was brief whatever it was.

CLARK: But you know that for sure?

CHUCK: Yeah, I should ask Win. Win may have more details on that. It would have been a footnote some place.

CLARK: Interesting. What was she like, her personality?

[41:19]

CHUCK: Very gregarious, outgoing. I mean, my father was the more staid serious one, and my mother was very outgoing, very social, lot of friends. Those days it was pretty much housewives, not a lot of women employed. I know she worked for awhile, but I’m not sure of those years. I can always remember just her being at home. The neighborhoods were full of people the same age so there was a lot of social life in the neighborhood, plus being smeltermen, you know, and the management circle. I remember their social life revolved around the company people. It was kind of a Madmen culture, you know martinis…

CLARK: Cigarettes.

CHUCK: Cigarettes, pipes, cigars, yeah.

CLARK: We should move to your dad if you’re up for that. I’m curious about his childhood. He had siblings?

CHUCK: Yeah, so there were three kids that grew up in that house. He graduated from high school and didn’t have the money to go to college, so he worked on the smelter for two years to save money to go to college. And then went to MSU and lived in the men’s co-op down there where everybody pitched in, did the cooking, and did the cleaning basically.

CLARK: I’ve never heard about the co-op. Ok.

CHUCK: Oh, yes. It wasn’t a fraternity but kind of a fraternity. It was probably the cheapest option there was as far as getting a degree down there and being able to work. He was in FANGS. He played basketball at MSU for awhile. FANGS was a service organization for the university. I don’t even know if they exist anymore. Changed degree majors several times. Mechanical engineer for a while. Chemical engineer for a while. He decided he didn’t want to spend his life in an office someplace. He finally ended up with a degree in civil engineering, but during that, it was in the ‘40s, he ended up commissioned into the military.

He went in, I think, as a lieutenant or a captain. He went to Europe in a tank war. They landed in Italy, part of the surge pushed through Italy and went into Austria and eventually into Germany, liberated some of the concentration camps. I’ve got pictures of him in gunner position int the tank. He said that they were with Patton for a while. He didn’t like to talk about it. So, I wish I knew a ton more, but it just wasn’t up for conversation.

CLARK: Ever?

CHUCK: Well not much. You’d see a picture or something here and there. Then when Germany was over, he went to the Philippines because Japan was still going on, so served over there. Talked a little bit more about that, but that ended not long after Germany. He had a lot of memorabilia that he confiscated from taking Japanese prisoners, pistols and swords. The same in Germany he brought home officer’s daggers and German lugers, and you know things like that. He had a Japanese ceremonial sword that he acquired over there.

He talked about getting shot at and bombed. The jeep getting blown off the road one time over there.

Then came back and finished school at MSU got the civil engineering degree and went to work at the smelter as a draftsman. You know the degree was in civil engineering so then he got out of there and moved into construction so was a construction boss for years up there as I was growing up and moving up the management ranks.

One of the things that I think that really helped him out a lot is that he had built a lot of the stuff on the smelter as it was expanding and growing and repaired stuff and he expanded stuff, so he knew the function of the plant really well. He eventually became plant manager of the smelter.

I grew up as a boss’s kid in a union town, but quite frankly, it was a really good upbringing. I didn’t feel that in my neighborhood, all the kids I was running around with, and it was on Main Street. I don’t know how many kids there were in the neighborhood, 10, 15 easily on the same block or within the corners that we lived on. You know, some one kid, two of them, four of them were from railroad families. One was a smeltermen’s family. A bartender next door. Across the alley hardware store. His kids, four of his kids, next to him the guy who owned the theatre, Washoe Theatre at one time, four of his kids. Big neighborhood full of kids that all played together and got along really well together. Yeah, I never felt any of the union company tension.

[48:02]

CLARK: During strikes? I’m curious how that affected your family.

CHUCK: Him more than anybody because there was always tension. A lot of the management ended up doing maintenance on the smelter and keeping things so that they would function when the strike was over, so they had to cross the picket lines to get in and do that all the time. He would tell stories, my dad would, about crossing the picket lines and some of the tensions there, rock thrown, and stuff like that going on. I think that they eventually came to know that there was two sides that were going to work together again. The tension was, I think, confined to a group of people, I don’t know how many at the time when the strikes were really going on in the late ‘50s, early ‘60s, I can remember more of that time, those being tough years.

CLARK: I’ve heard a lot about the bitter strikes in Butte, but I’ve not really heard much about them in Anaconda, which similar playbook. Did your dad talk about it? Was he sympathetic to the strikers, you know, demands at all?

CHUCK: He ended up on the negotiating team against the unions. I heard, I can remember now being old enough, to remember some of those conversations. He was very much a management guy. A lot of the people that I had in my practice afterwards that became my patients basically told me that he was really fair. They enjoyed having him as a boss, so I think he sorted out the things as I read it, if there was something not safe or needed to be fixed, they took care of that. The unions had demands as far as [phone rings], sorry.

Transcriber’s Note: Chuck takes a phone call and then turns off his phone.

[50:10- 50:53]

CLARK: Definitely want to hear more about labor relations and your father’s role in management, but if we can return to the war, real quick. You had said that he didn’t really talk about it, but you… did you find out from him about liberating the camps?

CHUCK: He just said they were part of it, that’s all I would get out of him as far as the horrors and the stuff they saw, no. He just wouldn’t talk about it.

CLARK: Do you think it affected him?

CHUCK: Oh sure.

CLARK: Long lasting in his life?

CHUCK: I don’t know, you know. We didn’t talk about all that.

CLARK: Yeah.

CHUCK: Yeah, didn’t have any pictures that he took or any of that. It was just kind of, we’re not going to talk about it.

CLARK: Wow, just did his duty and came home.

CHUCK: I guess. I don’t know how much Japan was part of that, and how big that transition was from there, but I know he came home and went zip, bang, stopped and left again.

CLARK: Interesting. I wonder if those experiences informed his management style, you know.

CHUCK: I don’t know. Yeah, I just don’t know. Be hard not to.

CLARK: Right. Ok. Can we hear the story of your parents meeting? Do you know that story?

CHUCK: I think it was high school or into college. I’ve heard at some of the cocktail parties that mom was dating the guy that later became judge. They ran with this guy so there was a lot of that going on, in those times, college and the war and stuff going on. I think they were married as he was getting ready to ship out. She took the train down or something to southern California, San Luis Obispo. It was like zip, bang, and he left again, kind of a war bride deal.

[53:22]

CLARK: Did he ever consider going to Montana Tech rather than MSU?

CHUCK: I think MSU was where it was going…yeah, I don’t think Tech was on the thing there at all…

CLARK: Right. I see.

CHUCK: If you wanted to be an engineer you went to MSU.

CLARK: I see. Ok.

CHUCK: I think, as he and I talked, I think he had good, really good math skills. I think that was part of the equation. Didn’t hear about a lot of the stuff going on then as far as college and stuff, you know, but I knew he changed the major three times before he finally settled on civil engineering.

When they put the electric furnace in, I think in the ‘60s – maybe the late ‘60s, he was the construction manager for that with McKee. He and my mom actually lived in San Francisco part of the year. They got him an apartment in San Francisco, and then he would stay there and then come back and supervise construction what was going on here, and go back and forth between the two. I was in dental school at the time that that was going on, early late ‘60s, early ‘70s, so we would leave Portland and go down and spend a weekend with them sometimes to live on the company credit card for a while.

CLARK: Alright.

CHUCK: Yeah, it was fun.

CLARK: Let’s turn to your upbringing if we can. Do you have siblings?

CHUCK: Sister, younger by three years, she lives in Missoula.

CLARK: I see.

CHUCK: She has two kids.

CLARK: Ok, so you said you were born in ’48 in Bozeman, but we’re not gonna… [laughter]

CHUCK: Hold that against me.

CLARK: Right. Shortly after, came here, so

CHUCK: Bozeman was interesting at that time!

CLARK: Really?

CHUCK: You’re young enough that you can’t appreciate this, but it was a cow town.

CLARK: Right.

[55:27]

CHUCK: The two sisters being nurses and graduating down there, married guys from Bozeman. One of them ran a slaughterhouse on the edge of Bozeman. The other one had an angus farm on the edge of Bozeman. And so, the other brother of those two guys had a meat market downtown, so they had the cows, the slaughterhouse, and the meat market.

And when I went to school in Bozeman, to give you an idea of, the platform for the chief of police was to stop college drinking, that was the biggest problem they had. It was, you know, as problems go, compared to where they are now, not a big deal. And good luck on stopping college drinking. So, they were kind of my go-to if I had problems in Bozeman, the two nurses. But the slaughterhouse got shut down pretty much as OSHA took foothold and the regulatory society took a foothold. The slaughterhouse was dumping stuff into the creek that runs along the edge of Bozeman, so not without good reason.

The angus guy, his ranch was adjacent to the college, so if you have to pick a piece of real estate you wanted in Bozeman, he had the best one. He raised angus and eventually retired from that. He had three children, one who ended up really high now in the Democrat National Party and lives in Florida. One of the gals became like a nurse’s aid, and one of them married a guy that ran the golf course in Bozeman. The kid that ended up working for the Democrat party probably ended up having more money than any of them. But when the mother and father died… When he retired, he sold off part of the farm and he and his brother bought a chunk of acreage out by Belgrade that ended up being adjacent to a golf course. They built the golf course next to their property. So, when they died and liquidated the real estate it was $14 million.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: In the ‘90s so those three kids ended up having to sell real estate to pay the estate taxes. Location, location… So, that was a side one of my father’s thing that, that affected that part of the family. Where were we going before we digressed?

CLARK: No, that’s quite alright. I had mentioned you had been born in Bozeman, that’s why we went back to Bozeman. I wanted to start in and hear about your childhood in Anaconda, and you had talked about the vibrant neighborhood, lots of kids your age in close proximity.

CHUCK: Yeah. Yeah, and good friendships, you know out of all that. There were times that I ran with railroad kids. They tied flies in their basement and taught me how to tie flies. The hardware store kids, his dad had Marchion Hardware down on – the building is even gone now, down on East Park. That was very much the movie Grease right behind my house, girls and guys and cars, all that going on in the neighborhood. We could walk into the hardware store and pick up a brick of 22 shells and a 22 and go up Sheep Gulch and shoot all day long if we wanted to, so yeah just typical good old 1950s, 60s neighborhood. Play outside until the streetlights come on and go home.

CLARK: Nice. Did you ride bikes and that kind of thing?

CHUCK: Yeah. Everybody had bikes. It gave us mobility all over the neighborhood and a good chunk of town. A lot of hiking in the hills. We had tree houses in Sheep Gulch and all that kind of stuff. Prowled around up there on the A Hill and the C Hill, so, I walked through all the smelter dust for pretty much my whole life.

CLARK: Yeah, I was going to say, yeah. Did you ever take trips to Butte as a family?

[1:00:43]

CHUCK: So my grandfather, Sonny, loved to go over there to eat at Raymond’s Supper Club. I can vaguely remember going up to Meaderville to Teddy Parish’s Rocky Mountain Café, vaguely, that’s just barely here. But Raymond’s, that was on the agenda whenever we went. Maybe the Red Rooster once or twice but Raymond’s a lot. Punched cards and stuff on the tables so you could gamble while you were having a cocktail. Good old Butte. That was my biggest memories of going to Butte, otherwise it was enough going on here.

CLARK: Sure, yeah. Did you ever ride the train? Was there passenger rail, do you know?

CHUCK: I did it after the smelter closed when they revived it between Butte and Anaconda. Otherwise, you know, when it was running with ore, no. That was verboten.

CLARK: Right. I see. No passenger rail at that time.

CHUCK: No, no. That wasn’t cool. I got exposed to ‘em when I was on the smelter and working on the smelter because they were up there all the time dumping cars and ore when east Anaconda was going on which was actually the west end of the plant. There was a structure called the tipple down there. So, they would bring the ore into there, dump it out of the cars onto conveyor belts that ran it up to the mills and that all got replaced. I can remember my father getting called out because that would freeze up in the winter time and I would go up there with him. We would go up and see what needed to be done to the conveyor belts, all the spills and stuff so… Yeah, but riding trains, no.

CLARK: Was he pretty much on call then all the time?

CHUCK: Yeah. He had a company car for as long as I can remember. Our first one might have been a ’54 Chevy, but after that once he started getting to be a boss that was part of the package, was the car. It was back and forth up to the plant all the time.

CLARK: Just in terms of the uh, I’m not sure if you know the answer to this, but the way the Anaconda Company was organized. The smelter was probably its own division, is that right? I’m curious how much he communicated with leadership in Butte.

[1:03:23]

CHUCK: Those guys all knew each other.

CLARK: Ok.

CHUCK: Because you know what was coming out Butte had to be standards for Anaconda, and so if, they were getting some bad stuff out of the concentrator, or the works in Butte, or the ore was not high grade, it’s like you need to work in another spot. So, it was all sampled in Butte, also in Anaconda, I worked in part of that process for a while in the sampling of some stuff.

At parties there were a lot of Butte people at my house in Anaconda. They would go to parties in Butte. There was, what was it called, a mining association and they’d have conventions in Vegas and they would all go to Vegas for the conventions.

Butte was one operation, Anaconda another, Great Falls another. I don’t think there was so much going on between Great Falls and Anaconda, but Butte and Anaconda were pretty tight.

CLARK: You hear about those efforts to displace neighborhoods in Butte to expand the pit, of course, Meaderville. I’ve always been really curious about the decision-making process for that internally within the company. I don’t know if your dad would have been privy to any of those kind of things.

CHUCK: Probably not in Butte. Anything over here he would have known about. When the Arbiter Plant was in that was kind of an adjunct, this big dream that was going to revolutionize things, didn’t happen. I can remember as the processes changed, and the environment became a little more important.

He took me up to the smelter because the water here was you know vastly important and the reason the whole thing was located here. So, I’ve got huge schematics of all the gallons that came out, from where, how much, how much was used at the Old Works, how much was used on the smelter, where it was used. When they started recycling some of the water they put in thickener tanks to run it through again and reuse it. He was really proud of that, took me up to show me how the thickeners worked, and how many gallons they were able to recapture before they ended up, you know, heading for the tailings ponds. It’s interesting.

CLARK: Definitely. Just a colossal industrial operation. It’s amazing.

CHUCK: Before it closed, this is a side note for you. I’m not sure of a lot of the facts and figures so you might shut that off for a second.

CLARK: Oh, that’s ok. Sure.

[1:06:37]

CHUCK: H2S, I think, hydrogen sulfide at different spots for years in the valley, but it became more prominent probably in the ‘70s, so they had us right where highway 48 cuts off, there was a station there, another one down by Gardiner’s Farm, in Mill Creek there was one. I don’t know if they had one in Lost Creek. The prevailing winds from the smelter came down off of the divide and down, carried predominantly the smoke down the valley. To get an east wind to carry it into town, if that happened 10% of the time, I’d be surprised. Most of the problem went that direction. When they set emission standards, God knows how, for what happened downwind and if the H2S exceeded a certain level for a certain amount of time, they had to shut down the converters.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: It means you quit producing whatever is going out the stack and you quit producing copper so that’s big bucks when that happens. I can remember being really controversial. And the standards were set somewhat arbitrarily from the state, I think it was DEQ. So at any rate, the point I’m getting to make is when the smelter closed down, everybody is looking for somebody to blame, and the company has this part of the problem; the unions were getting too much demands so labor was part of the problem, blah, blah, blah; maybe what was coming out of the stack and the pollution is part of the problem. Within a very brief time, I can’t remember the months involved, my dad told me that whoever was governor at the time called DEQ and said, “I want you to lower the emission standards for the testing stations because we don’t want to get blamed for the smelter getting shut down.” You hear what I’m saying? There was politics involved too, part of the whole thing.

CLARK: Always is.

CHUCK: Yes. Might have been Tom Judge, but I can’t remember. You can turn it back on if you did shut it off. Yeah. But, I think as a matter of fact, the reason it got shut down was bean counters in some place in New York or Denver.

[1:09:45]

CLARK: Denver, yeah.

CHUCK: Denver, that had never been here before but wasn’t penciling out the way they wanted to so just shut her down. So, I’ve heard that from some pretty good sources that were involved in the negotiations afterwards and the closure and all that stuff.

CLARK: I am making some notes and definitely want to get back to this notion of the closure

CHUCK: When I moved back here my father told me, said “there’s always going to be a need for a smelter. We need copper. We’ve always got to have a smelter so moving to Anaconda is not a bad decision because that’s just the way it’s going to have to be.” He is right. There is a need for a smelter but not here. A lot of these concentrates go to Canada and the very southern border of the United States where nobody can see the pollution so, they’re still making the copper, not here.

CLARK: So, there was a sense, really, that it was invincible.

CHUCK: Absolutely.

CLARK: I want to be sure that we touch on as much as we can of your personal history, so I guess I want to hear memories of high school. [laughter] We talked a little bit about your college education and we’re going to return to that, but yeah, what was high school like here?

CHUCK: Looking back on it, I felt I got a good education. I know that there were some really bright kids in the high school that went on to do good things and got accepted to big, good universities and stuff. I don’t think there is anything that I would have to say that was bad about it. I mean we had a lot of extracurricular stuff, there was speech and debate teams and science clubs. The stuff that I was interested in and I wasn’t a big sports guy, I did play a little here and there, some football. As far as getting an education, yeah. At the time nothing seemed out of place, it was all, this is how everybody does it and we’re in a good place.

CLARK: Was the specter of Vietnam hanging over your class?

CHUCK: Oh absolutely, yeah. I don’t know of any high school class that graduated that has lost more to Vietnam than my class. A lot of kids went in, graduated in ’66, a lot of the kids went in right after high school and didn’t come home. That took a huge chunk off my class right off the bat.

[1:12:52]

CLARK: Do you remember some of those people?

CHUCK: Yeah, yeah. And we’ve got some really good people in the class that do reunions and keep everybody updated on who’s dying and what’s going on. [laughter] It’s on facebook, of all places. We lost some good people right off the bat.

CLARK: Who were some of those, if you care to recall?

CHUCK: A kid named Dave Anderson that I probably knew a little bit. I have more good memories of Vietnam from the friends who lived. I grew up in high school with some of those guys. Three of them ended up in the Navy, one in intelligence, one on a river boat- gun boat, and they all learned how to get through it.

There was one intelligence on the boat who was stationed out and was doing intelligence work offshore. He probably had the best situation.

The other one that was on the river boat came under fire all the time. He basically survived because the first time they came under fire, or maybe not the first time but one of the times, you get off the deck and go down below decks where you’re protected by a lot of metal. Jumping down the deck he hit his forehead on the bulkhead going down and broke his glasses in half, so he figured out, if I break my glasses, I’ve got to go back to Saigon to get a new pair. He went through a lot of glasses on that river to stay out of harm’s way. They also did a lot of gunnery work and came under fire a lot doing some of that.

One of my other buddies, probably the guy I was closest to, was in the Air Force just outside Saigon. He was in probably the best spot of all of them. Everybody depended on their mail coming and going, so Charlie figured out, he and his buddies in the mail corps there, he ended up working for the Post Office here afterwards, figured out don’t mess with the mail guys because you’re not going to get your paychecks, letter correspondence from home.

Everybody figured out how to work the system in Vietnam. I’ve heard that more guys figured out how to survive if you survived. I did the same thing in the Dental Corps. There were some interesting stories. The guy in the Air Force was probably a good thing is grandfather died who was a doctor in town because that’s who raised him, so Charlie got to go home before his grandfather died because he was starting to get in the black market for dollars. He contacted me and said, “for every dollar you send me, I can get you back 10.” I didn’t have a dollar at the time! They paid all their bills with the care packages that the Red Cross would send and stuff so yeah it was interesting. Vietnam was an interesting time.

I ended up in dental school when I went into the early enlistment program so basically said, I’ll go in as a dentist out of dental school. We had no benefits from that until my senior year and somehow, they got $1500 for each of us. I have no idea why. We got a check. We had a certificate that changed us from a second lieutenant to a first lieutenant my senior year. Then, I went in as a captain, but I had nothing to do with it at all, anything until I took my physical to go in which is a fun story because I went down with all the recruits that were going into the military at that time to the recruiting center. There was a resident doctor med school that was doing the physicals, probably 40 of us in this room. They go through the thing, how many of you guys have graduated from high school or not graduated from high school, how many have graduated from high school, how many of you guys have graduated from college, how many guys beyond college. So, I’m getting ready to take my physical to go into Dental Corps, so I get through with my physical and he calls me into the office. He says, “Do you want to go into the military?” I said, “yeah.” He says, “Why?” and I said, “for the experience for me, a selfish reason, but dental school is good. Two more years of experience before I go into private practice would be even better.” I broke and dislocated this shoulder in high school my senior year. It’s got a pin in it, muscle displacement. He said, “I could keep you out of the Dental Corps because of your shoulder.” He said, “However, you would still be eligible for the draft and could go in as an infantry man.” I said, “Well, where that’s where you hold a rifle.” He said, “I know. Catch-22.” But he said, “If you want to go into the Dental Corps, I’ll sign off for you that you’re fine to go.” I could not be a dentist and pack a rifle, that’s how the Army worked.

CLARK: Pretty easy choice for you, but yeah, strange.

CHUCK: My draft number was 55 so I was going you know, no matter what happened. That was ’66. 1969 got out of MSU. And then ’73 got out of dental school. First duty station, Win and I drove across the country to Fort Belvoir Virginia, set 12 miles south of DC, big engineering base. West Point Prep School was there so if you didn’t get into West Point but thought you were good material you could spend a year there, and then you had a good chance of getting into West Point. Night Vision College was there. That’s where they developed a lot of the infrared stuff that they now use routinely, it all came out of there. We serviced huge metropolitan area for trauma so that was a good duty station.

I had an internship there. I actually gave them an extra year so I could get the internship, rotated through oral surgery, periodontics, crown and bridge, didn’t have to do fillings for a year, Periodontal surgery, prosthetics. The program was brand new, so it had only been in existence for a year in the military. The instructor was a little Italian guy, and he said, “What do you want to do? If you want to do 80% academic work? 80% clinical?” He said, “We’ll structure it, whatever you want to do.” So, we said, “how about 95% clinical and 5% academic.” He said, “you got it.” We went to Walter Reed every two or three months they had a weekend where a lecturer would come in, or several of them. They brought dentists in from all over the Eastern seaboard there. That was the sum total of that didactic portion. We went up to Walter Reed for a couple days every couple months which was perfect. We all loved it. That was a good year.

From there we went to Korea. We were initially go to Stuttgart. The other three guys all had kids. Win and I didn’t have children at the time and so they said we would like to send you to Korea because that’s a little tougher on guys with children. To show you how the system works, Win probably already told you this, she was working for Senator Mansfield at the time. His Montana office manager was a gal named Peggy, and she said, “Win, do you guys want to go to Korea?” Win said, “Well why?” She says, “Because if you don’t want to, the Senator can take care of that for you.” So that Creedance Clearwater Song, I’m not some senator’s son song, that has special meaning for me. [laughter] We decided that we wanted to go to Korea because that would be an adventure.

We ended up going to Korea. Drove back across the country. It was an unaccompanied tour, but she could come over apart from that. I flew out of Travis Airforce Base in California on Flying Tigers, to Anchorage, Japan and then Seoul, and then, I was a dentist over there for a year. After I was there a little more than a month, Win came over, and we got a house on the economy and lived in the village. She taught school at Osan Air Force base. I was a dentist at Camp Humphreys, that’s where I learned to work the system. [chuckle]

CLARK: What do you mean by that?

CHUCK: The base I worked at had 120 helicopters on it. It was a helicopter base for the whole country. I think there were five dentists and five doctors at the clinic there. The lieutenant colonel that I worked for, this was his third tour in Korea, married a Korean on his first tour there, pretty little lady, but knew the system better than I did. He basically didn’t want to work. The NCO in the clinic cooperated with him in fudging the production numbers like he was working, so he was never there. He could play all he wanted to, show up once a week, “How are things going? Have a nice day.” But that put me in charge of the clinic because I had the most experience, I had the internship. So basically, it’s like Chuck, if there’s a problem, you take care of it.

Well, there were a certain number of things you were allowed to do on GIs and certain things you couldn’t do. One of the things you couldn’t do much of was crown and bridge work. You could fill teeth, routine fillings, pull teeth, take care of the troops, chief dentistry. There were some of these guys that needed crown and bridge work, prosthetics, partials, whatever, so I did it. I sent the lab work to Alameda on the Air Force planes and it came back, so I had a little crown and bridge practice running for GIs. Some of those guys that were over there, corporals and privates ended up with some pretty good dental work in their mouths, and I got the experience of doing it. The military was doing it at a lot of bases in the states so there was no reason that they shouldn’t have been doing it there. At any rate, I thought it was kind of a win-win for everybody, that’s how I rationalized it.

CLARK: And the repercussions for you?

CHUCK: None, none. Checking out a country… I learned to fly over there. I got my pilot’s license in Korea. Most of the instructors were all pilots running helicopters, whatever. We got to know those guys really well. Anytime you needed to go anywhere you took a helicopter. Win and I headed up to Seoul. We had a couple vehicles when we were there, but otherwise, just chopper rides here and there. It was pretty cool. Being a captain over there was pretty high rank. I had another dentist friend who went to the DMZ. His sister was a pretty good friend of Win’s. He found out he was ranking officer at the DMZ. The other guy there, in charge, was a captain also but a little longer time than him. Dennis said they sent me to the DMZ thinking that you know, this is a bad deal. He said, “I went up commandeered a jeep and an aide and did whatever I damn well pleased.” And he did, and so as he said this isn’t a bad thing. I think there were three dentists up there, something like that. He said, we did our job, but life was ok.

[1:27:55]

CLARK: Did you ever go up there and take a look? What was your impression?

CHUCK: Well, we went to a ceremonial spot of the DMZ where they show everybody where the two sides sit across with guards on each side of the border. One day for the hell of it, we wanted to see the DMZ from the air. Another friend of mine found out there was a Chinook training mission going, which are the two big blades on the huge choppers to do a map of the earth tour of the DMZ which means you’re flying at low level overall, everything. We got onboard and saw the DMZ from a Chinook for 2.5 hours one day.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: It was like after 45 minutes; it was like let me off this thing. You know, you’re smelling aviation fuel and hydraulics and you’re doing this even though you’re close to the ground you’re going like this, it’s like ok I’ve seen the DMZ. It’s full of tank traps, all kind of anti-personnel stuff. They say it’s all full of mines and stuff. A lot of gun placements on both sides. It’s not some place you want to hang out. Seoul is the same way. You see machine gun placements behind billboards. It’s in the city.

CLARK: Really?

CHUCK: Tensions at the time were kind of high. You know, it was right after the Pueblo. I don’t know if you know about that. The North Koreans captured a US small boat and took all of them prisoner on the Pueblo. They were always sneaking spies South, you know, and probably the same thing was going from the South to the North, but you never heard about that. We had nukes over there at the time. There were a ton of no-fly zones. I swear we still do have whether we admit it or not, but at the time if I flew in in training in that Cessna over a nuclear site or close to one, we’d take tracer rounds.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: It was serious about it. Interesting place.

CLARK: That sounds very lively.

CHUCK: Yeah, yeah. So, if you had your map and they said you’ve got a radio transmission that basically turn around, you turned around, it’s not like, I don’t want to, you want to. A lot of friends in the Air Force told us a lot of stories that were a lot harrier than that. Where were we? We digress all the time.

CLARK: That’s fine. That’s fine. That’s perfect for this kind of thing. Do you look back on that time fondly?

CHUCK: Oh yeah. The experience was good. We made good friends when we were over there in the Dental Corps and in the Officer Corps. It was a good experience. We took a USO tour of the Orient for two weeks: Hong Kong, Bangkok, Singapore, Tai Pei. We traveled a lot through Korea. There’s an island, Jeju-do, that was volcanic off the southern coast and we went down there for a long weekend and snorkeled, toured the island, and drank. [laughter] Yeah, yeah, it was all good. We traveled a lot in Korea, went all the from Busan up to the DMZ and some of the resort areas, yeah.

CLARK: And culturally were people there accepting of your presence, you think?

CHUCK: Very friendly. After the Korean war in the south, the Koreans were helpful. It’s kind of like we spend time in Mexico now, and it’s kind of like the way we’re treated in Mexico is like we help them, and they help us. It’s a nice symbiotic relationship.

CLARK: Did you like wearing a uniform?

CHUCK: I did. Yeah, yeah. The year that we were in Korea, I feel, gave me a better appreciation of the military than I had way before that even at Belvoir because there were real wars over there. Guys who fought for their country. We had a lot of guys came back from Vietnam there. A lot of those guys had war stories if you could believe a half of them, it’s unbelievable. I’ve seen scars on those guys’ bodies from shrapnel, bullet holes, you know medivac guys that got shot up. The air base being close by, a lot of F-4s coming and going and we knew a lot of those pilots and so… I have great admiration.

[1:33:16]

CLARK: After that did you guys come right back to Anaconda?

CHUCK: No, we went to Fort Ord in California so 55 dentists on that post. They pretty much closed the place now, but it was a huge base. I came from Korea, and they put me in a clinic, and I don’t know what they call it, amalgam, just filling teeth. I’ve got all this training for…

CLARK: Surgery.

CHUCK: You know, the last two years before that had been awesome. So, I’m in this amalgam line for about a week and I went to the major that was the head of this whole thing. I’m still a captain, and I said, “I can really increase your numbers, my production for you guys” because they were really pushing production at the time, “if you let me run my own appointment book.” I said, “They’re giving me 45 minutes for one filling. I can do three fillings in 45 minutes.” I said, “Or if it takes an hour to do them, you’re still going to get more work out of me”, and I said, “it makes sense.” You know, I said, “It would be good for me. Good for you.” He said, “Let me think about it,” so he comes back the next day and says, “I can’t do it.” I said, “Why not?” He said, “I have to do it for everybody if I do it for you.” I said, “Well, that kind of makes sense too, doesn’t it?” “No, I can’t do that. We’ve got all these women employed that do scheduling at the front desk. What am I going to do with them?” Let them make the appointments. They wouldn’t buy it.

So, I’m in the coffee room within a couple of weeks and somebody comes in and said, “There’s somebody at the front desk, this colonel, and his kid who is 8 years old has a cavity. This guy is a dentist, but he says he can’t work on his own son. Can you work on him?” I said, “Hell yes. Bring him in.” I go back, take care of the kid, so his dad is a lieutenant colonel in another clinic, running the prosthetic department over there, crown and bridge, and partials and stuff. So, he said, “What do you want to do?” I said, “Anything but this.” He said, “Why don’t you come work for me?” “Sign me up,” so that’s how I got out of the amalgam line, and went into a different building -small shop, and this guy is board certified prosthodontist, and they’ve got a wait list of 9 months to get crown and bridge work done, so it’s like, here we go. So, that’s what I did the rest of my tour there, was basically work the crown and bridge prosthetics, doing that stuff. So, that turned out to be a good deal too.

CLARK: Very good experience. What is it that compelled you to go into dentistry in the first place?

CHUCK: My parents encouraged me to choose a profession where I was my own boss because he was working for the corporation. My grandfather was working for himself, but he said, you don’t want to be a mechanic, you don’t want to be in this, you should be your own boss. Part of their social circle was a dentist. Sometime in the conversation with him and my folks he said, you should come down to my office and see what I do. He let me look over his shoulder a little bit. I thought well this kind of meets some of the requirements and looks like it would be good work. I need to interrupt this for a minute because my bladder is saying that’s enough, Chuck.

CLARK: You bet. I’ll pause… I often, I try not to go to the dentist, but when I do, I often joke that it seems like my dentist is a sadist. Is that a common theme among dentists?

CHUCK: Oh, you get all kinds of comments. You know, I had a fun practice. There was a good upbeat attitude and stuff. It was a happy place to be, a happy place to work, a lot of my patients told me the same thing. It was not a threatening environment.

CLARK: Good. [Laughter] It’s just the drill inside the head is just unnerving. Right.

CHUCK: Oh yeah, I’m not crazy about it myself.

CLARK: So, at Fort Ord, what was your time like outside of work in that period in your guys’ life?

CHUCK: It was the same as DC because we were tourists. We knew that we were only going to be there for 11 months so let’s make the most of the experience. I was not a big golfer, which like a lot of those people on that base did that’s what they did for recreation, was golf. I did some duck hunting when I was down there. Did some scuba diving in Monterey Bay and Carmel when I was down there. Win and I traveled a lot when we were down there just around California and that area, just looked at it like another vacation time for 10 or 12 months.

CLARK: I see. And you at that time were you planning to return home? Ok, so you knew you were headed back this way?

CHUCK: Yeah, didn’t know where but Montana basically. We were fortunate because we’ve got east coast, west coast and overseas, kind of diverse perspective on what was going on in the country and stuff.

CLARK: And so much valuable experience that allowed you to launch your own practice, I guess.

CHUCK: Exactly, yeah. Things fell into place. They needed a little nudge here and there.

CLARK: And so, was it, if I recall from Wini’s interview, was it ’76 that you guys came back?

CHUCK: Yeah.

[1:39:47]

CLARK: I guess I would be curious to hear about that trip and that whole transition.

CHUCK: I was wanting to go to Missoula, and then talked to a couple guys, and was discouraged. They basically said we’ve got enough dentists here, don’t come. Eddy Bartoletti was practicing here. His wife Lee Ann and Win were sorority sisters, she probably told you this, in Missoula together. He went to dental school a year behind me. I talked to Eddy, and he said, “I’m killing myself. They just got insurance on the smelter. There is massive need.” He said, “I’ve got like 30 root canals going at one time. I just can’t handle any of this”, so he said, “there’s tons of work here.” So, I thought to myself, that sounds good. That’s kind of what brought me back here, there was a great need and the outdoor recreation for me was like, oh yeah this is no longer California, boy, don’t have to stand in line to do anything.

CLARK: Did the smelter have a unique effect on teeth at all?

CHUCK: Yeah, in a lot of different ways. Probably when I came back that was an opportunity to help clean up some of what was going on through a whole bunch of things. Fluoride programs were just coming into the fore at the time. Preventative dentistry was coming in to its own at that point in time too, so you could do a lot of education work, plus a lot of restorative work on stuff that had been done, change people’s mentality, it was a huge, long transition. You know, as far as the damage that had been done. You couldn’t say it was the acid smoke. A lot of it was job related. I mean, you would see guy’s teeth worn out from holding nails in their mouth all day long and doing things just kind of stuff like that. Diets, a lot of teeth ground down, a lot of tongue – lot of smoking going on, a lot of lesions for that, didn’t see a lot of oral cancer but some more from the smoking cigarettes than from the plant. There were spots that if you weren’t doing what you’re supposed to, it had effects on the skin, a lot of acidic stuff going on in the mouth, but you wouldn’t say, oh that’s caused by the acid plant or something. You died from other stuff more serious than that.

CLARK: I see. [laughter]. Oof. How about Anaconda at the time of your return, what was the mood here then?

[1:42:51]

CHUCK: I’ve often told people it was like going into Germany after the war. Because Urban Renewal was going on, the government had these huge programs to restore downtown areas into vibrant urban areas, so they were tearing apart a lot of the old historic buildings in downtown Anaconda. So, that’s why I say it was like going into Germany after the war got out because where Pizza Hut is, where Glacier Bank is now, where the Chamber of Commerce, all of that was being ripped out. The big advantage for that, is that there were low-cost loans for new businesses available. Low cost at that time was 8.5% and 6.5%. They said 6.5% on some of your clinic loan was like, wow, that’s really good. Now, people are screaming like, are you kidding – I can’t afford that, so it depends upon what was going on when and there.

The town was not pretty downtown as far as when that was going on. We bought a house two blocks down the street from this one, and were in there for two years. There was a readymade building to go into my old dentist office’s building, it was an old doctor’s clinic so he gave me his old 800 square feet ,and he was across the aisle from me in a spot he had remodeled which was about another 800 square feet. It was small but that’s how I got going, you know. I think I was booked out six weeks before I got ready to practice.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: Yeah. As far as building a practice, it just happened on its own.

CLARK: And the smelter, you mentioned began offering dental insurance, that was a new program at the time?

CHUCK: Maybe a year before then Delta Dental came in as part of the union negotiation deal, they got dental insurance for pretty much everybody up there. When the company bosses had it all the workers ended up getting insurance also. Some of the people had never seen dentists other than for a toothache their whole lives. There was a myriad of stuff. Thank God for all the training I had, you could pretty much handle everything.

One of the things I learned in the military, that one three-month period I did nothing but surgically remove teeth in the hospital, so you learn how to extract teeth. I had some really good teachers, and I lot of guys these days coming out of school never pull teeth. They send them all to the oral surgeon, that’s who pulls teeth. The periodontist pulls teeth. Even when I was practicing, just a lot of guys didn’t want to pull teeth. A ton of my practice initially was getting rid of some of the horror stories, saw abbesses and all that stuff for treatment, just getting people healthy again.

CLARK: Do you derive satisfaction out of that?

CHUCK: Being able to cure their illnesses? Yeah. Not so much digging in through abbesses and stuff.

CLARK: [laughter] Yeah, I have a lot of respect for people who work in medicine. I could not do it myself.

CHUCK: Yeah, it’s a transition. It’s basically when you start school you think, I can’t do this either, they walk in and there is this surgery suite with eight chairs going on and people pulling teeth and triangles of blood coming down and you think, [heavy breathing]. After about six months it’s like, let me in there, I want in there.

CLARK: Nice. Ok. How about your family, you all kind of began to start a family when you came back, is that right?

[1:47:23]

CHUCK: So, Win and I didn’t have kids for a long time. So, we adopted the two boys when I was 40. She was 39.

CLARK: I see.

CHUCK: So, yeah, much would consider that later in life which has its advantages and disadvantages. Obviously, we were more affluent at that point in time, you know, but also older to raise kids. Some of the things that you wish you could do with them, but I still did some coaching with them and tried to get them in the outdoors and all that stuff. There are two sides to that coin. I think it was good for them and us, as much as they piss me off from time to time. [laughter]

CLARK: That’s what children are for.

CHUCK: That’s exactly right.

CLARK: And why did you all decide to adopt?

CHUCK: Infertility problems. Don’t even get me started, you’ll be here all afternoon. [laughter]

CLARK: [laughter] Ok.

CHUCK: That phase of medicine was not very sophisticated in the late ‘80s.

CLARK: I see.

CHUCK: A lot of that was just in the forefront, and yeah, so some interesting things that they do to ya, with ya and for ya. I had a friend in Alaska who was going through the exact same thing at the same exact time I was going through it. We used to tell each other stories about how they were checking our sperm counts and oh my God, yeah. Probably not for this recording, it would take some heavy editing.

CLARK: I understand. Ok. It was after the closure of the smelter then that you all decided to adopt children and raise children in the Anaconda post-smelter. The town must have fundamentally changed, you know, when the smelter closed. I just think that it’s almost a courageous decision to then start raising children here.

[1:49:44]

CHUCK: Probably, I mean there was a whole bunch of things that factored into the decision to stay. I’m sure she told you all those.

CLARK: We touched on it a little bit.

CHUCK: One thing, the practice was good, and the practice was going. As the dental insurance dropped off, Bartoletti and I worked our tails off because all a sudden we’re going to be without dental insurance, Eddy and I are going nonstop. People were really appreciative that we were working to accommodate them. The practices, his practice was good and so was mine. A whole lot of people that didn’t leave, who weren’t employed up there, a whole bunch that did, but you know, we thought let’s just – even if we stay for a few years, if this thing looks like it’s really going downhill, we’ll still have the experience of living here and this that we can fall back on. I never even looked at another place, let’s stick this out and see how it plays out which is what we did. I have never regretted that decision at all.

There were years, you’re right, the real estate market was in the toilet and a lot of empty houses, a lot of businesses left as you might imagine happened. I’m still making a good living, still got a good patient base, the people were paying their bills. I thought that would be the biggest problem, people were still paying their bills. So, the people that stayed with ya were good, so it was a transition but look back on it now and think it’s amazing that it worked out that way. It didn’t affect my lifestyle as far as hunting and fishing, that was still out there and good. My spare time was good. We were building a place at Georgetown, so that kept me out of trouble.

CLARK: There is more to Anaconda than the smelter and its closure, does it, you know, disturb you that people dwell on that?

[1:52:32]

CHUCK: For a while, I saw, and my attitude on that has morphed over the years, it absolutely destroyed some people’s lives, immediately after the fact, that was their life. Some of these guys, that was their identity. You can say that the same for someone that’s in private practice or something like that, I know lawyers that way. Some of them, you never saw them again. They had no outside interests. All their friends… what happened to the town, what I really miss, a lot of the crafts – the really skilled workers up there left down to Gillette and Colstrip while that was under construction and in a couple years the families left because the guy found good work down there and a place to live. A lot of those people I missed, because a lot of those were more my age and fun to be around and stuff. Some of the people that stayed and were morose and down in the dumps and depressed because of it, I would see now and then in the office. It was bleak for a lot of those folks, and tough to be around. I can understand that point of view, but after several years it’s like, get over it, k. It’s not coming back so move on. So, then my attitude towards the whole thing was like if you’re still here, figure it out, quite complaining about it all.

CLARK: Was there a perception at the time, how do people perceive the Anaconda Company as opposed to ARCO when they moved in?

[1:54:37]

CHUCK: Well, ARCO came in before they closed.

CLARK: Right.

CHUCK: So, you know a different thing going on, but a lot of the people running the place were still the same.

CLARK: Oh, I see.

CHUCK: Yes, so there wasn’t a huge deal there except you’re negotiating with somebody different than the Anaconda Company, now you’re negotiating with the ARCO people. And so, I don’t know how to answer that, I wasn’t a part of that whole thing, I had my own world to live in.

CLARK: Sure.

CHUCK: I don’t think for my dad, you know, it made a huge difference in him as far as his outlook or the job he had to do. He actually I think had spent a lot of time with Sandy Sash afterwards. They became very good friends. Sandy was a good friend of ours. I learned a lot about ARCO through Sandy and that relationship. Of course, he was a big star witness in the trial, you know, they sued against ARCO.

CLARK: Tell me about that if you would.

CHUCK: Well, I mean, when the state filed the action against them for the cleanup, there was a judge and a trial, and banks of attorneys involved in that from the state. I’ve heard this from a bunch of different sides, through Sandy and some of that, but also, I’ve been involved with NRD in cleanup and some of those lawyers and people that were their engineers told me about my dad’s role in the trial and his relationship with the judge. My dad had a really good memory so he was on the stand, I think, five days talking about the plant, what it did and all this as part of that lawsuit. I had some of the NRD people who were suing, and he was a witness for the company, tell me how knowledgeable he was and how much he and the judge hit it off. My dad even told me the judge told me I should write a book. I said, I think you should too, but he never did. Too bad. Your job would have been so much easier. But he knew how the place worked.

CLARK: And the result of that lawsuit?

CHUCK: So, the state ended up with a huge amount of money. I forget how many millions, hundreds of millions. You probably know as much about it as I do, basically it was set up for remediation and restoration and replacement. I actually spent some of that money for them.

CLARK: How’s that?

CHUCK: In the early 2000s, part of the settlement was you could replace lost resources, so some of the lost resources would be like the wetlands where the ponds are now or maybe the slag piles and tailings ponds where habitat was lost. They were pretty much open for whatever came their way as a replacement.

One of my friends Chris Marchion in the Sportsmen’s Club, and he and I had known each other for a long time through the Sportsmen’s Club, we’re talking about it at one time. I think he used some of the money to acquire some of the watershed lands west of Anaconda, small piece up by Echo Lake someplace. At the time Dennis Washington was involved with land ownership at Georgetown. They picked a lot of that up just as part of the deal of getting the concentrator in Butte.

They had subdivided Rainbow Point. They developed it, and put really a ton of homes on small lot sizes up there, and everybody’s going… There’s no rules and regulations regarding development at the lake. The next piece they wanted to put up for sale was Stuart Mill Bay and that chunk of property. I called up Chris and I said, boy, do you think those would qualify for NRD money? He said, it’d be perfect for NRD money.

So, we got a bunch of guys involved with the homeowners association up there and we had been working on land exchanges with Washington Corp, and they were not doing good for a whole bunch of reasons. It’s complicated. At any rate, started talking to NRD, do you think we can acquire this piece of property, would it fit. The initial impression was, a gal named Carol Fox was running the program at the time, and she said, bring me a proposal. We went to Washington Corp and their land manager through Mountain Lion was a guy named John Crowley. John had run a bunch of the previous land exchange attempts between the lease holders and the people that were on Washington’s property, and they were trying to – it was really complicated, trying to exchange Forest Service leases with land Washington Corp so these people could end up buying their property. It was Forest Service because Forest Service can’t sell you the land. We knew Crowley because of that, we said, “How about we use NRD money to buy Stuart Mill Bay from you guys.” There were no homes on it. It was pristine property. He said, “Well, I’ll tell you what we won’t do, we won’t work with the Forest Service.” He said, “I’ve had it with those guys, it takes too long, the last one with them took five years to get to the point where they were ready to make a deal and the Forest Service had said that land values had changed and wanted a new appraisal.” Washington Corp said after five years, kiss off, we’re out of here. So, he said “I won’t work with those guys.” So, I said, “how about we have a grassroots organization, homeowners, sportsmen, carry the ball so if something happens and it goes south, you’re not to blame.” He said, “that’s what we want.”

Fish, Parks and Wildlife had to be a part of that because they were going to be the final owner of the property. One footnote to start with that, we all met. We started talking about how to structure this whole thing and the guy that was the regional advisor, Mack Long, was the guy out of Missoula who ran Region 2 went to the press because he’s patting himself on the back, we’ve got a potential deal going to acquire this piece of property at Georgetown, and mentioned Washington Corp was a part of the whole deal. Crawley calls me up and said, “We’re going to be the bad guy again if this falls on its face, Chuck.” I said, “How about if we get him out of the equation.” He said, “That works for me.” I called Mack up, I knew him, and I said, “You’ve gotta step aside”. I said this is why and told him the two things, what was going on, they just don’t want bad publicity. I said, “You’re still going to end up with a feather in your cap and owning the property, but you can’t do the initial part of the deal.” He said, “ok.” Basically, a few of us carried the ball through the whole NRD process, all the hearings, we got an outfit called the Conservation Fund out of Sun Valley, but they work nationally. Dick Channey happened to be on their board of directors at the time with Dennis Washington, that was like perfect, got another good republican on the board. They bought into the Conservation Fund and what they were going to do was interim financing. We would get the money, and they would safeguard it until the money came through from NRD. A long story short that worked. We went through a long negotiation process on what’s to be included, structured, money. I can remember being at the chair working with a phone on my ear doing dentistry talking tens of millions of dollars. By the time we got done, I think it was under $4 million, just under $4 million, to acquire the piece of property for the public. NRD, I’ve has got some experience with those guys, and still have some people, some in-roads to that outfit and work with them now. It’s been good.

CLARK: The Sportsmen’s Club, can we hear about that?

CHUCK: That was a thriving organization when I came to town, that and TU were the two clubs I joined. The Sportsmen’s Club used to meet in the armory, have big banquets down there every year. FWP came in, tons of guys came in from Fish, Wildlife, and Parks. That sheep herd that’s up here drew a huge number of people to this area. Our fundraisers were good. We acquired through state lands, the campground on the Big Hole, that’s another story for a beer sometime.

CLARK: Yeah, I’ll take you up on that.

CHUCK: But the club was great, I was president for a few years. Marchion was the president. Gary [Ouldhouse] is the president now. I think his dad was president for a while. What’s happened is, now, it’s a bunch of old guys going to the meetings. You can’t get young people involved. Everybody is doing their own thing and doesn’t want to do a lot of volunteer work. The club, the membership is way down. The amount of good we can do is way down. You know, you have got to really pick your projects. The club has still got a really good reputation as having a lot of clout and pull. We combine with Sportsmen’s Club in Butte, Skyline on some things, public lands and water access. Butte and Anaconda have always been really tight in doing that work and so we still have some influence in some projects that way. Otherwise, it’s pretty much, Chris does a ton of it, so does Gary, through the Wildlife Federation and legislature.

CLARK: What is the mission of the club, in your own words?

CHUCK: This one? Boy, right, that’s tough. You know, it’s got- we’re involved in a whole bunch of things and we shouldn’t be, we should be more focused. We spent a lot of time of game regulations; land owner relationships; loss of public land access is a huge part of what we’re fighting against all the time; the game range out at Mount Haggin, we spent a lot of time and energy on that. Otherwise, it’s like I keep them informed on Georgetown and TU stuff. I’m way more active now in TU than I am in the Anaconda Club. We’ve got a great board and do a lot of work.

CLARK: Tell me about Trout Unlimited. Is it a statewide organization?

[2:07:52]

CHUCK: Yeah, I don’t know if there are 11 chapters in the state. We are quite regional. We have the Big Hole, Jefferson, Boulder, we can kind of cover an area that is not well defined. We may overlap on Flint Creek with West Slope out of Missoula, and the Clark Fork, they’ll have the lower part, we’ll have the upper part. The Butte Chapter is pretty much that area. I think there are 17 guys on the board right now.

CLARK: Wow.

CHUCK: That are all, probably 15 of us, are very engaged. We’ve got $300,000-$400,000 in the bank right now to work with. The banquets every year are raising $100,000. There is probably 10-12 projects a year we can donate to, and plus, graduate students get some of our scholarship money that are working in their fields on fisheries and the rivers and stuff. I feel really good about what’s going on with them, we’re making a difference, and it’s going to good things. Kids camp, bringing kids into conservation and teaching them how to fly fish at Georgetown and stuff so, … I left TU in the ‘80s because it was in such good hands to take care of Georgetown because Georgetown needed help at the time. There was a lot going on up there, that’s part of what getting Stuart Mill acquisition, so I was kind of the guy just looking after Georgetown. I got involved in lawsuits over the water up there against Granite County and Trout Unlimited was part of those lawsuits, sued the commissioners over there a couple of times. It’s been kind of my baby, and I still babysit to this day. I got involved with FERC, filed complaints with FERC.

CLARK: What is FERC?

CHUCK: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. They take care of all the dams in the United States.

CLARK: Sure, FERC, ok.

CHUCK: That FERC. It has been an education. A lot of good has come out of it and the lake is healthy today more so than when I got involved.

CLARK: Do you consider yourself an activist?

CHUCK: Yeah.

CLARK: [laughter] That’s good. What about the state of…

CHUCK: An old activist

CLARK: Well still, an effective one, it sounds like. The Upper Clark Fork today, do you know? What is the state of it in your mind?

CHUCK: I don’t know if we’re ever going to fix that problem.

CLARK: Yeah.

CHUCK: I know what it would take to fix it, but the money is not there.

CLARK: What would it take?

CHUCK: Hundreds of millions. You know, the corridor has been largely cleaned up. But the Warm Springs ponds are a huge problem, that should have been drained and all of that relocated or treated, and all that is left in place. I can tell you what’s underneath those ponds, it’s not good. Everybody can tell you what’s underneath that water. That’s why they have this bird area for recreation to cover up all that, to get the public to accept all that, and the public pretty much is.

CLARK: Do you think wrongfully?

CHUCK: Yeah. If you want to clean up the fishery and the river, that’s got to be part of the equation. Everett will tell you that, all the people that have been dealing with this will tell you that. A lot of the lawyers will tell you that. NRD people will tell you that. It’s been litigated and NRD has their money out of that. Unless you do another lawsuit, I don’t think it’s going to happen. Temperature is a problem. What’s coming out of the pit in Butte, people don’t like to hear that especially my friends from Butte, but they know it. You can’t be starting water at 70 degrees out here and expect that to be a thriving fishery, and sometimes it is above 70 coming down Texas Avenue area. No matter how much water comes down from Warm Springs, Mill Creek, or Willow Creek it’s not enough. It’s dewatered heavily, and all the good water that is coming in is going to ag in the valley. They’re by rights and by negotiation, they’re entitled to that water, you know. I don’t know if it's doable. It’s doable, but feasible?

CLARK: The will is not there currently, right?

CHUCK: No.

CLARK: So, you don’t approve of waste in place.

CHUCK: No.

[2:13:23]

CLARK: So then, in your mind would the cleanup effort here be insufficient, just inherently, since that’s the basis of it?

CHUCK: Probably. You know, and some of the cleanup money has been used wisely, some of it hasn’t, for sure. I think a lot of people that dole the money out would agree with me on that. I go down and I look at the restoration now and tour what’s been done, and it’s not pretty. I don’t know if you’ve looked at it, but they’ve got, supposedly, the soils moved back away from the waterway and put in plants that haven’t grown well, banks that are eroded and things are washing away, there’s no structure, there’s no habitat. I wouldn’t live there if I was a fish.

When I moved back here, I could go down there in the evening with a dry fly between Galen and Warm Springs and catch 15-17 fish in there. No problem. You can’t do that now. That was when the smelter was running!

CLARK: Not an improvement.

CHUCK: No.

CLARK: Did you by chance, did you ever work with Mary Kay Craig? Do you remember her from Butte? She was involved a little bit with Trout Unlimited, George Grant chapter.

CHUCK: That doesn’t ring a bell to me at all, probably the years that I wasn’t there. What years was she there?

CLARK: More recently.

CHUCK: Ok. I got back on the board 6 years ago.

CLARK: Ok.

CHUCK: She wasn’t on the board then.

CLARK: She passed away maybe 4 years ago.

CHUCK: Ok.

CLARK: But anyway, I was just curious, she was also an activist. Why Georgetown specifically? Why is that body of water important to you?

CHUCK: Well the family has had a place up there ever since the nineteen teens, so you know, my great-grandfather, there are old photographs of him up there with these two old structures. They had a little piece of property that they camped out on, on Stuart Mill Creek. Sonny eventually acquired that property in 1952 from the Bowmans who had the place around it, so it was actually an inholding there but with an easement to it.

I basically grew up there. I would go up there with Sonny and work on weekends, recreate up there, and grew up, up there. One of the guys that worked for Sonny in the recap shop sold, Sonny wanted a piece of property on the lake farther up, so he sold him 1/3 of an acre up to his place up there. Sonny put in a boathouse and I ended up with that piece of property and built my place on Georgetown, I’ve got some landownership up there now on the shoreline which is nice to have. I grew up fishing up there. Duck hunting up there. I’m pretty familiar with the whole thing. Did you ever know Wayne Hadley?

CLARK: No.

CHUCK: No, so you’ve probably heard the name a few times.

CLARK: It is a familiar name.

CHUCK: Wayne was a biologist friend of mine. I’ve got great videos of Wayne shocking fish. I shocked some fish with him. I worked on the lake with Wayne. We had a great time. Weeds were a huge problem for a while.

The water usage has been the major problem up there of what’s going on. When the Montana Power Company was running it, it wasn’t a big problem. It was pretty much a done deal.

When they decided to get out of that nobody wanted it because owning a dam, especially a hydrodynamic dam is not profitable. Granite County decided they wanted it to protect the irrigators downstream. They basically acquired it in part. They didn’t get the power plant, but they got the work license. The first bad year we had they proceeded to start to drain the lake for irrigation.

[2:18:34]

CLARK: Hence the lawsuit?

CHUCK: Hence the lawsuit. So, that basically, over the years, the problem is there is the government that changes all the time running the place with different spheres of influence with those people, different ideas on how to manage it. There’s a FERC set of rules that they just as soon not look at for years. It’s like this is what we’re going to do so we had the result of the lawsuit, people involved in how it was going to be managed, people that didn’t have any power trying to work with people down there. There was Fish and Game involved, US Fish and Wildlife Service, Forest Service involved, counties involved, irrigators have a 1906 decree on what they’re entitled to which is part of the license, there’s historical usage that a lot of the agency basically viewed as the management plan. What has been going on for 75 years should continue going on. There’s some reasoning behind that. I did the same as you when I first heard that, times change!

CLARK: Right.

CHUCK: However, they’re protecting certain interests, and I understand that the fishery is one of them which is a big interest of mine. At any rate, that has now because of our actions pretty much has become a routine that is being followed. This year has been a good test of it because of the drought that is going on. We had to file complaints with FERC to get them to adhere to the terms of the license. Basically, they were running it for the irrigators instead of for the fishery and the lake health. We had to go to extremes to make that happen. You complain to FERC and if FERC takes action, the penalties are massive, $10,000 a day in some instances.

CLARK: High stakes game.

CHUCK: High stakes, yes, but that is what it takes to get some people’s attention sometimes. Now basically FERC says manage it for hydropower not irrigation, and they’ve been trying to do that. That’s only been going on for 2 years. This year, usually irrigators ask for water and get it now, they’re keeping the outflow the same with what the irrigators are entitled to which is what should be done by law.

CLARK: And you enjoy this work?

CHUCK: Sometimes. Sometimes it’s very frustrating.

CLARK: And it’s all volunteer.

CHUCK: You make a lot of people mad. A lot of people pat you on the back too.

[2:22:15]

CLARK: What do you think the biggest threat is right now to public land access and fishing access, waterway access in Montana?

CHUCK: Out of state money, of course.

Big, big ranches coming in that are a couple of things: 1) not producing cows and 2) they’re recreational playgrounds for very wealthy people. It’s happened dramatically around us. I was talking to a forest service ranger out in Pburg about it yesterday. He says, Chuck, it’s not just the lake and what’s going on there, it’s everywhere I work. He says, you go into Seymour Lake. He says, there’s more people in there at the trailhead than there ever has been, and it’s all people that have moved into the area or relocated in the area. Georgetown has massive building that is going on, you wouldn’t believe what’s going on. The developments on Rock Creek, the Ranch at Rock Creek, the Meadows right below that, all that hunting access has been lost in that area. I used to hunt elk up there and you can still get in there. You can get in the way I used to, walk from the bottom up, but a lot of guys can’t do that. I can’t do that anymore, but all that access has been lost. All those lands have been locked up. Those people that come in and hunt the elk on those lands. Absolutely.

I hunt some now in New Mexico right now in the Boy Scout ranch down there. I’ve got a good friend that got me in down there. Northeastern New Mexico is, I don’t know how much is private, but it’s massive lands. It was all the old oil barons in Texas, east Texas, wanted a place to play so they bought huge chunks of New Mexico. And Philmont, the Boy Scout ranch which is 180,000-acres was the old Waite Family Philips Oil. He donated it to the Boy Scouts with some caveats, it had to be kept a working ranch. But Ted Turner’s Vermejo Park is next door to that, some 800,000-acres; the U U Bar is next to that is over 200,000-acres; you’re talking 25 miles from one end of the ranch to the other. You talk about losing public access, that whole chunk of the state there’s a couple little tiny places of public land, the rest of it is all private owned and probably the minimum price per tag is about $10,000 to get on some of that land. A lot of those people are very wealthy and buying places in Montana because they’re already bought up in New Mexico, I’ve been on them.

CLARK: Do you see any way to reverse that trend?

CHUCK: I don’t see how you’re going to reverse it. You can protect what you have left though. You know, private property rights in Montana are very strongly protective. I’m glad for that, but you better fight hard for what’s left, you know. Some of these things they want to change the wilderness area designations on some of those things like Daine’s is wanting to do, that’s part of that. Public land, water access, that’s… one of the guys on TU’s board is running that now, Alex. Do you know Alex?

CLARK: Leone? I do.

CHUCK: Yeah, I figured you would.

CLARK: Yeah, we’re acquainted. Sometimes I run into him at Gallicano’s [laughter] or an event in Butte. I imagine he would be a good team member to have on the board.

CHUCK: Yeah. That’s some of what the club does down here, fights for stuff like that. And Chris Marchion has been massive in that. He’s basically acquired $31 million worth of real estate between Georgetown and Anaconda through NRD, Elk Foundation, exchanges, Fish Wildlife and Parks, that’s a lot of real estate. One guy through the club has basically made that happen. They can bad mouth him in the paper all they want, but he’s been a good guy as far as I am concerned.

CLARK: [laughter] Maybe we could talk all day like you said, but maybe to conclude, usually what I like to do is ask people to, you know, what do you hope for, for the town that you live in. In our interviews in Butte, I’d ask what do you hope for the future of Butte. Obviously, here, what do you hope for, for the town of Anaconda?

CHUCK: That’s difficult for me and I’ll tell you why. There’s two sides to that coin. I want the town to be affluent. I’m really happy to see the young people moving into the area. There are a lot of engineers here. A lot of business people here. Some of those people are working other places. A lot of the young people are working other places. So, I’m happy to see the growth of the business community and the services that are provided.

I’m not so crazy about what is going on in the rural areas, a lot of those places that I used to play and have really good fishing and really good hunting, are deteriorating. So, with growth comes responsibility, and it is not being taken care of. We’ve got to take care of those resources.

I have mixed feelings about saying that I really want the town to grow and that’s what you’re going to hear from the people in town because I’ve seen what it was, kind of what it can be, and what it has become.

CLARK: So, you just have to manage that growth responsibly I guess.

CHUCK: Absolutely, absolutely. You know, and I’m getting too old to do it. It’s going to take some younger people to step up and make that happen. Because a lot of the people that are driving that, are driving the dollar. That brings more people, more stress on the resource.

CLARK: Well, here’s hoping that that growth continues but doesn’t get out of control

CHUCK: But is managed, that’s the key to the whole thing. You don’t want to start building houses where there shouldn’t be houses. There’s a lot of places you can put houses that don’t have a bad impact. A lot of those places, people don’t want them, they want them in the places where they’re impactful. I want my mansion on the banks of the Big Hole!

CLARK: Right! Right.

CHUCK: I’m guilty of that. I built my mansion on the banks of Georgetown, you know, albeit 40 years ago.

CLARK: You’re grandfathered in at this point.

CHUCK: Yes.

CLARK: Well, Chuck, thank you so much for sharing all of this with me today. I really enjoyed visiting with you.

CHUCK: Yeah, it was good fun.

CLARK: Yeah, there is always more to cover but perhaps in a subsequent session.

CHUCK: Oh yeah, for sure. If we’re both here, right?

CLARK: Yeah, thank you for that

[END OF RECORDING]